How buying works in Glastonbury’s Buttonball neighborhood — the homes currently listed, the real prices from the deeds, and how to be ready when the right home hits the market.
Buttonball — Recently Sold · Homes for Sale
For Buyers
Buttonball has 444 homes and about sixteen sales a year — so at any given moment there are usually only a few homes listed, and the well-priced ones don’t wait. Buyers aim here for the same reasons sellers do well here: Buttonball Lane Elementary School inside the neighborhood, the Glastonbury school path behind it, lots around six-tenths of an acre, and no HOA.
The homes currently listed are below, with their asking prices and MLS numbers. When one isn’t on this page, it’s because it isn’t on the market — call Adam and he’ll tell you what’s on, what’s coming, and what each asking price looks like against the recorded sales.
On the Market
$650,000
3 bd · 1.5 ba · 2,010 sq ft · 0.54 acres
Colonial, built 1957
MLS #24210297 · Listed September 27, 2026
William Raveis Real Estate
Reduced $40,000 from its original $689,900 ask. A brick-front colonial a short walk from Buttonball Lane Elementary.
$650,000
4 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,920 sq ft · 0.39 acres
Colonial, built 1978
MLS #24200116 · Listed August 21, 2026
Finnegan Realtors LLC
A classic four-bedroom colonial with a family room fireplace and a primary suite, minutes from the elementary school.
$624,900
4 bd · 2.5 ba · 2,092 sq ft · 0.57 acres
Colonial, built 1964
MLS #24209354 · Listed October 3, 2026 · Under contract — accepting backups
eXp Realty
Bought for $480,000 in April 2026 (it’s in the sold table), extensively renovated, and back on the market as a move-in-ready colonial.
Listing information from SmartMLS listing pages, checked November 14, 2026. A listing’s status and price can change at any time — call Adam at (860) 773-4412 to confirm a home is still available before you plan around it.
How It Works
In a neighborhood where the good listings draw multiple buyers, a pre-approval that’s already underwritten is the difference between touring a home and owning it. No association approval is needed — Buttonball has no HOA — so your financing is between you and your lender.
Asking prices are opinions; the sixteen recorded sales on this site are facts. Before you offer, compare the home — street, style, size, lot — against the deeds in the recent sales table.
Most Buttonball homes date from the 1950s–1970s, so a thorough inspection matters. Your lender’s appraiser will work from the same neighborhood sales — another reason the deed table is the page to know.
No resale package, no association questionnaire, no transfer fee to a condo association. A Buttonball purchase closes the standard way, and the deed records with the Town of Glastonbury.